Friday, 8 August 2025

PIERRE POILIEVRE ON THE HOT SEAT FOR A SEAT!

 

PIERRE POILIEVRE ON THE HOT SEAT FOR A SEAT!

 

I have always been fascinated by politics as in the Machiavellian aspects of the game, the intrigue behind the scenes, the jostling for position and who will get to wear the slightly tarnished crown of leader, anointed for an unspecified amount of time because politics is a fickle enterprise and the only certainty: it will all come to an end, sooner or later.  Poor Pierre is struggling after losing his own Ottawa riding in the general election.  A party leader without a seat can’t attend any parliamentary sessions.  Rather embarrassing for a leader who anticipated a majority win, a coronation of sorts.  So did his party.  Until it all unraveled in the form of Mark Carney and a Liberal party always willing to seek out partners across the political spectrum.

There is no such thing as a guaranteed win.




It had all the political pundits baffled.  Riding high in all the pols leading up to the election?  Why did he lose an almost forecasted win?  And . . . after losing his own riding, why didn’t he step down?  Why are the voters from Battle River-Crowfoot contesting Poilievre’s nomination with such vehemence and hostility?  The riding held by former MP Damien Kurek should have been a shoe-in as he won it with 83 percent of the popular vote.  Alberta has been a hotbed of political discontent for a very long time and with Daniele Smith at the helm stirring the pot at regular intervals it has been playing with the hearts and minds of Albertans.  All provinces take turns feeling sorry for themselves, it is an ingrained phenomenon in all nations that have provinces, states or territories.  Most of them conveniently forget that predominantly federal initiatives have helped shape a nation.  Consistently pulling together only happens under extreme circumstances.

Proud to be Canadian.  Proud to be nice.

Canadians are not Americans.  For Canadian voters trust is important.  Confidence and a steady as she goes approach.  By and large Canadians are nice, hard-working people.  What they crave most is economic stability, predictable progress and a healthy and safe environment.  Canada didn’t have a Wild West, a Civil War, slavery and an urge to be the biggest and the boldest player on the world stage.  We‘ve had our flirtations with upheaval but not to the extent of our neighbor to the south.

 Personality matters.

Poilievre’s brash attitude and attacks made a lot of people feel uncomfortable.  Too much of an imitation of the tempestuous leader that emerged in the United States.

We love our nation.

Mark Carney struck a lot of the right notes at the right time.  He appears calm and decisive and not prone to rash statements.  He also has a remarkable legacy and pedigree in all things economic and the state of the economy is front and center in the minds of all Canadians.  Especially since there is this one particular person south of the border who is determined to wreak havoc with the global economy.  Carney’s message was simple and it stayed on point: protect Canadians and the Canadian economy.  Protect Canada!

So, why didn’t Poilievre step down as leader?  Most leaders would!

Why didn’t he step down and why did the Conservative Party stick with Poilievre as their leader?  The Conservatives came awfully close to winning and at one point all the poles suggested a huge Conservative majority.  Close but no cigars and no brilliant heir apparent waiting in the wings willing or able to reignite the party.  The loss was too sudden and unexpected.  Poilievre may win this by-election, but it could well be by the smallest of margins.

What do Canadians look for in a leader?

An astute leader needs to be able to “read” the temperature in the room and messaging has to be strong and believable.  Carney’s greatest strength is his ability to keep his mouth shut, especially if he’s not sure about the right answer or how to best answer an awkward question.  America’s infatuation with Trump is shrinking at an alarming rate because he can’t keep his mouth shut.  A volatile, loose cannon, fun for a while and highly entertaining, but his value as a trusted leader is diminished with every new gaffe, lie and fabrication.

A great leader has to have the right mix of decisive leadership, a sense of humor that comes shining through at the right moments, but also a person who demonstrates an ability to connect with people on many levels.




Sensitive Western toes.

A record number of candidates have come out to challenge Poilievre in the upcoming by-election.  The voters in Battle River-Crowfoot feel betrayed by their own MP; And . . . by someone from Ottawa!  Of all places!  Had it been a backwater riding in Ontario or Quebec it may have created a stir, but for many in Alberta, Ottawa is like a red flag being waved in the face of an angry bull.  And Smith has stirred that pot to the max!

Politics is all about timing and seizing the moment and momentum.  Justin had his Dad’s name and reputation to fall back on.  He was also a dapper, good-looking young man, affable and congenial.  Mark Carney has a rock-solid financial pedigree and being able to steer an economic ship in the right direction in these precarious times, especially when we’re faced with an American president whose economic ideas border on the insane, on bluff and bluster and lacking substance, couldn’t come at a better time.

Voters are fickle and any form of permanence is lacking in the world of politics as voters get easily bored.  It is not the die-hards that swing the votes, it is the fickle swing voters that cast the deciding ballots.  Regular mandatory elections are the bane of all political parties and the reason why so many wannabe autocratic hopefuls crave dictatorships.  Dictators are overthrown in rebellions and civil wars and everybody else gets defeated at the polls.  In democracies it is the unhappy, the grumpy and dissatisfied that sway the balance on the political teeter-totter, never the die-hard party faithful.

The lure of winning.  It is always about the win.

You can analyze Poilievre’s rise and battles from any angle, from gains to losses, costly mistakes and successes, from what if only, to what if he only had done this or that, you will never find certainties in politics and a win is never guaranteed.  But Poilievre is desperate to hang on and it goes a long way in explaining why those who get the kiss the brass ring and wear it for a while are always reluctant to give up the crown and to gracefully retreat into public obscurity.  Power is a weird aphrodisiac.  Especially when it comes with some mighty attractive perks.  You only have to take a close look at the antics from the clown running the White House!




An anxious Pierre will be holding his breath as the moment of truth will arrive on August 18.  But even a win may not be enough to convince the party.  I wouldn’t be a bit surprised when a new leadership run is announced.  All parties want their leader to win.  Losing or second best is never an option in politics.

Feel free to comment or share.

No comments:

Post a Comment

GROWING TROUBLE

  GROWING TROUBLE   Not that long ago we were mere scavengers as we left the jungle behind for greener pastures, venturing out into a wo...